357 maximum vs 44 magnum. 41, and . , 240 at 1760 fps, 6. 0 lb. 44 magnum for self defence which would you choose and why? To put it simply, if you have to carry only six rounds, would you sacrifice power for lighter recoil or would you go full tilt and take . Smith December 31, 2025 The . 357 Magnum's (125gr JHP at 1500 fps) 479 ft-lbs. 44 Magnum generally has a larger bullet and more stopping power compared to . rifle - 6. 44 Magnum debate, you’ve got to go back to the roots. 44 Magnum are famous for their blazing speed and strong punch in handguns and carbines.